Preview

Preview data. Not yet reviewed. Every finding below was researched with AI and is public so anyone can check it. People have not signed off yet. How review works

Governor

Governor, Vermont

November 3, 2026 · 8 statements · 2026.09.23-ee547f20

  • Not yet reviewed by a person.
  • The candidate list has not yet been checked against the certified state list.

Candidates

  • Amanda Janoo

    Democratic

    Sourced positions on 5 of 8

  • Phil Scott

    Republican Incumbent

    Sourced positions on 8 of 8

Also on the ballot

  • June Goodband Other party Not researched: below our published threshold
  • Brian Judd Independent Not researched: below our published threshold
  • Dean Roy Other party Not researched: below our published threshold

We research every Democratic or Republican nominee, every incumbent, and anyone who raised at least $50,000 (per the FEC) or reached 5 percent in a public poll. Methodology

Statements and positions

AgreeDisagreeNo clear position Select a position to see the evidence behind it.

State statements

EducationNo. 1/8

Vermont should merge its school districts into a smaller number of larger districts.

Background

A 2025 state law set a process to redraw Vermont's school district map into fewer, larger districts and change how schools are funded. Lawmakers have not yet settled on the final district boundaries.

Amanda Janoo Disagree

Instead of building on this strength, Vermont's current education strategy is focused on consolidating districts, closing rural schools, and sending children farther from their communities.

Campaign or official site · Mar 12, 2026 · retrieved Sep 23, 2026

Once you close the schools, you're pretty much giving up on the town.

Press quote · Mar 12, 2026 · retrieved Sep 23, 2026

Verification
Quote found on the cited page by an independent check.
Confidence
High (0.80)
Review
Not yet reviewed by a person.

Phil Scott Agree

First, we need far fewer districts each serving far more students.

Campaign or official site · Jan 7, 2026 · retrieved Sep 23, 2026

Verification
Quote found on the cited page by an independent check.
Confidence
High (0.80)
Review
Not yet reviewed by a person.

TaxesNo. 2/8

Vermont should raise income taxes on its highest earners.

Background

Vermont's top income tax rate is 8.75%. This would add a higher rate or surcharge on incomes at the top of the scale.

Amanda Janoo Agree

will be funded through our Fair Share Tax Proposal, which asks the wealthiest Vermonters to contribute

Campaign or official site · Mar 12, 2026 · retrieved Sep 23, 2026

Verification
Quote found on the cited page by an independent check.
Confidence
High (0.85)
Review
Not yet reviewed by a person.

Phil Scott Disagree

We have one of the most progressive tax (systems) in the country. I think we should think long and hard about what this really could mean to the state.

Press quote · Apr 15, 2026 · retrieved Sep 23, 2026

Verification
Quote found on the cited page by an independent check.
Confidence
Medium (0.60)
Review
Not yet reviewed by a person.

TaxesNo. 3/8

Vermont should tax second homes at a higher property tax rate than primary residences.

Background

Vermont's statewide education property tax already sorts property into homestead and nonhomestead classes. This would set a separate, higher rate for second homes such as vacation properties.

Amanda Janoo Agree

Luxury second homes, commercial vacation rentals, vacant investment properties, and large corporate or private-equity ownership would contribute more

Campaign or official site · Mar 12, 2026 · retrieved Sep 23, 2026

Verification
Quote found on the cited page by an independent check.
Confidence
High (0.85)
Review
Not yet reviewed by a person.

Phil Scott Disagree

But that money already pays for something else. So, what program or service would you like to cut, and for how long?

Campaign or official site · Jan 20, 2026 · retrieved Sep 23, 2026

Verification
Quote found on the cited page by an independent check.
Confidence
Medium (0.65)
Review
Not yet reviewed by a person.

Health careNo. 4/8

Vermont should use public funds to cover primary care visits for all residents.

Background

Primary care in Vermont is now paid for through private insurance, Medicaid, Medicare or out of pocket. This would have the state pay for primary care for every resident, funded through taxes.

Amanda Janoo Agree

Guarantee free primary and preventive healthcare for every Vermonter by eliminating copays, deductibles, and insurance barriers.

Campaign or official site · Mar 12, 2026 · retrieved Sep 23, 2026

Verification
Quote found on the cited page by an independent check.
Confidence
High (0.90)
Review
Not yet reviewed by a person.

Phil Scott Disagree

Vermont took a very different approach, and the opportunity to build more options was set aside to pursue a government-run single-payer plan that failed after years of empty promises and millions of dollars.

Campaign or official site · Jan 20, 2026 · retrieved Sep 23, 2026

Verification
Quote found on the cited page by an independent check.
Confidence
Low (0.50)
Review
Not yet reviewed by a person.

Health careNo. 5/8

Vermont should create a single public health plan that covers all residents.

Background

Vermont passed a law in 2011 to plan a single-payer system but dropped the plan in 2014 over its cost. This would replace most private coverage with one state-run plan funded through taxes.

Amanda Janoo Agree

Lay the foundation for universal healthcare by creating the nation's first publicly funded universal primary care system...and creating the infrastructure needed to expand toward comprehensive universal healthcare over time.

Campaign or official site · Mar 12, 2026 · retrieved Sep 23, 2026

Verification
Quote found on the cited page by an independent check.
Confidence
Medium (0.70)
Review
Not yet reviewed by a person.

Phil Scott Disagree

Vermont took a very different approach, and the opportunity to build more options was set aside to pursue a government-run single-payer plan that failed after years of empty promises and millions of dollars.

Campaign or official site · Jan 20, 2026 · retrieved Sep 23, 2026

the Legislature pursued healthcare policies, culminating in Act 48 in 2011, which directed the state to design a taxpayer-funded single-payer healthcare system.

Campaign or official site · Jul 8, 2026 · retrieved Sep 23, 2026

Verification
Quote found on the cited page by an independent check.
Confidence
High (0.85)
Review
Not yet reviewed by a person.

Energy and climateNo. 6/8

Vermont should remove the right to sue the state over missed greenhouse gas reduction targets.

Background

The 2020 Global Warming Solutions Act sets required cuts in the state's emissions and lets people sue if the state does not act to meet them. A lawsuit over the state's missed 2025 target has been filed.

Amanda Janoo No clear position

We found no public vote or statement that answers this. It is not counted.

Verification
Quote found on the cited page by an independent check.
Review
Not yet reviewed by a person.

Know a source? Challenge with evidence.

Phil Scott Agree

If we want to protect Vermonters, we have to remove the provision that allows special interests to sue us, which, by the way, is already happening – and it will slow down progress.

Campaign or official site · Jan 28, 2025 · retrieved Sep 23, 2026

Verification
Quote found on the cited page by an independent check.
Confidence
High (0.85)
Review
Not yet reviewed by a person.

HousingNo. 7/8

Vermont should exempt more housing projects from Act 250 land-use review.

Background

Act 250 requires state review of many larger developments for environmental and community impacts. Recent laws exempted some housing in designated areas, and this would widen those exemptions.

Amanda Janoo No clear position

We found no public vote or statement that answers this. It is not counted.

Verification
Quote found on the cited page by an independent check.
Review
Not yet reviewed by a person.

Know a source? Challenge with evidence.

Phil Scott Agree

So, we'll again present a package to continue to modernize Act 250. It starts with extending the interim housing exemptions to 2030.

Campaign or official site · Jan 20, 2026 · retrieved Sep 23, 2026

The addition of the Road Rule is a significant expansion of Act 250 that will make it harder to build.

Campaign or official site · Jun 13, 2024 · retrieved Sep 23, 2026

Verification
Quote found on the cited page by an independent check.
Confidence
High (0.85)
Review
Not yet reviewed by a person.

Public safetyNo. 8/8

Vermont should give judges more power to hold people in jail before trial.

Background

Vermont's constitution guarantees bail for most defendants, with exceptions for some serious crimes. This would widen the cases in which judges can order someone held until trial.

Amanda Janoo No clear position

We found no public vote or statement that answers this. It is not counted.

Verification
Quote found on the cited page by an independent check.
Review
Not yet reviewed by a person.

Know a source? Challenge with evidence.

Phil Scott Agree

We also need to make it easier to revoke bail, limit the ability to reduce or suspend sentences, seal criminal records instead of erasing them and provide more tools to hold repeat offenders accountable, including funding to expand last year's pilot for pre-trial supervision.

Campaign or official site · Jan 28, 2025 · retrieved Sep 23, 2026

Verification
Quote found on the cited page by an independent check.
Confidence
Medium (0.60)
Review
Not yet reviewed by a person.